Norbert's American Flyer Trains - Controls

December 23, 2015
doerry@aol.com


(click picture to view)


I developed the circuits below for my own use. Hopefully I provided enough information for you to adapt these circuits for your own needs. You can always send me an email if you have any questions.

Controls -- November 2001
Close up of the Automatic Control System for Christmas 2001

Controls -- December 2002
Automatic Control System for Christmas 2002

Controls -- December 2003
Automatic Control System for Christmas 2003

Controls -- December 2007
Automatic Control System for Christmas 2007

Controls -- December 2009
Automatic Control System for Christmas 2009

Controls -- December 2011
Automatic Control System for Christmas 2011

1. Track Trips

1.1 Current Trips

Dual Current Track Trip
Dual Electronic Current Trip

Electric Track Trip

Electric Track Trip

Current Trips sense if the train engine is drawing current from a block of track. I've built two different types of current trips. The first is purely electronic in that it uses a transformer and electronic circuits for the sensing. The second is an emulation of the American Flyer #26722 Electric Track Trip and is purely eltro-mechanical with a solenoid and a microswitch. In use, this one has a bit of a voltage drop that results in the train engine slowing while in the control block

Dual Electronic Current Trip
Electric Track Trip

Sparkfun offers a breakout board for the fully integrated Hall Effect based ACS712 current sensor. This current sensor is ideal for American Flyer applications because it senses both AC and DC currents. The output of the sensor is an analog signal between 0 and 5 Volts that can be connected to an analog input of an Arduino (or other microcontroller) to determine the magnitude of the current.

Current Sensor and Block Control for Arduino
Current Sensor and Block Control for Arduino

Current Sensor and Block Control for Arduino
Current Sensor and track polarity control for Arduino

1.2 IR Track Trip

IR Track Trips -- November 2001
Close up of the IR Track trips used to detect when the train exits the shared section.

I always wanted to play around with IR sensors, so I thought this would be a good project. I've seen a lot of circuits that are based on an IR LED and phototransister that detect whether IR light is received or not. These circuits typically have problems with interference from other IR sources. This circuit is based on using the IR LED to transmit a 38KHZ IR signal that is detected by a an IR module (like that used for Television Remote Controls) and should be much more reliable, but a bit more complicated. On the down side, the IR sensor that I used is too large to hide in the tracks. I constructed a building to house the circuit and integrated the sensor into the roof. I also incorporated the IR LED into a Block Signal.
IR Track Trip Circuit

I'm also using IR Track Trips made by TCH Technology. These trips are designed to be installed under the track, but since my layout is built directly on the floor, I had to construct buildings to house the trips.

IR Track Trip House
Inside the IR Track Trip House

Here's an exit trip implementation (located at the exit switch) using the Sensa-Trak II tm built in December 2007. This trip included an interface board.

IR Track Trip - Exit Trip using Sensa-Trak II tm

IR Exit Track Trip using Sensa-Trak II tm

In general, the reflective IR trips work well if sunlight isn't filling the room. Had problems during the day time with trying to keep the sensors from being saturated. At night, all worked well.

The following is another exit trip implementation using a beam interruption circuit. I tried using a Radio Shack 276-640 IR Receiver Module, but couldn't get it working reliably. (Need to do some more experimentation). Went back to using my last IRM 8420 module.

IR Track Trip - Exit Trip using Beam Interruption
IR Track Trip - Exit Trip using Beam Interruption

IR Track Trip - Exit Trip using Beam Interruption Circuit

The previous IR-Track Trips worked well on my floor Christmas Layouts, but they took up too much room on my permanent layout. Hence some minor changes were needed ....

IR Track Trip - For Permanent Layout
IR Track Trip - For Permanent Layout

Control box for IR Track Trip - For Permanent Layout
Control Box for IR Track Trip - For Permanent Layout

IR Track Trip Circuit

2. End of Train Processor
End of Train Processor
End of Train Processor

One of the problems with most track trips is that while they are good for detecting when the train arrives, they aren't that good for signalling when the train has departed. This circuit generates a pulse when the train has successfully passed a track trip.
End of Train Processor Circuit

3. 696 Track Trip Conditioner

AF 696 Track Trip Conditionere
AF 696 Track Trip Conditioner

The American Flyer 696 track trip provides a connection to one of the train rails when the wheels of a car or engine presses down on a shoe and forces two contacts together. This is great for controlling accessories that need A.C. power, but not so great if you are using D.C. control circuits. This circuit uses a relay to isolate D.C. control circuits from the A.C. of the 696 trip.
AF 696 Track Trip Conditioner Circuit

Alternate AF 696 Track Trip Conditionere
Alternate AF 696 Track Trip Conditioner

This alternate circuit allows you to connect to either rail of the track and uses optoisolaters to isolate D.C. control circuits from the A.C. of the 696 trip.
Alternate Track Trip Conditioner circuit

4. Block Inhibit Signal

The following circuit is used to generate a Block Inhibit signal to the controller based on either a switch direction sensor, or a manual input. For the switch Direction Sensor, I modified a remote control switch by adding a small reed switch and gluing a magnet to the light "shutter." The reed switch closes when the switch is in the curved condition. The following circuit enables one to invert this signal (low value when the switch is in the straight direction) or apply a signal manually.
Switch Direction - Block Inhibit Signal control box
Switch Direction - Block Inhibit Signal Control Box

Switch Direction - Block Inhibit Signal Control Box Circuit

5. Remote Switch Controller

5.1 Relay Based

Remote Switch Controller
Remote Switch Controller - Dec 2003

Improved Switch Controller
Improved Switch Controller - Dec 2003

I built my own switch controllers because I needed ones that would enable me to either control the switches manually (local control) or enable the control system to automatically set the switches (automatic control). The circuits I developed also add a safety feature that prevents the control system from burning out the switch by energizing both coils at the same time.

Switch Controller
Improved Switch Controller

5.2 Power FET based

The following Remote Switch Controller is entirely solid state using Power FETs. Its also somewhat less expensive than using relays.
Solid State Switch Controller board
Solid State Switch Controller Board - January 2015

Solid State Switch Controller
Solid State Switch Controller - January 2015

This controller is intended to be controlled entirely by an Arduino; the controller does not have a local control capability. A remote switch coil is energized by grounding the appropriate input. Note that if both inputs are grounded, neither remote switch coil is energized. Two sets of terminals for the AC accessory power (on the 4 pin terminal on the end) enable daisy chaining of multiple switch controllers

Solid State Switch Controller

5.3 Switch Emulator

Switch Emulator
Switch Emulator - June 2015

The following circuit is used to emulate a switch and its direction detection for use in developing automatic controls. When trying to debug software on an Arduino or other controller, its more convienent to not have to use the actual hardware. This circuit can emulate two switches. The "coil" inputs are defined in the same manner as in the controllers described in 5.1 and 5.2. The "switch direction" outputs are defined in the same manner as the switch direction detection circuits in section 6.

Schematic and Drawings for Switch Emulator

6. Switch Direction Detection

The following controllers are designed for manual throwing, but provide feedback to the control system as to the direction the switch was thrown. The first example taps into the lights of a normal American Flyer switch controller and provides an optically isolated digital signal. It will fail if the controller lights are not on, or if the switches are manually thrown. The second uses Atlas Snap Switches to do the same thing. The atlas snap switches are hooked in parallel with the switch machines and change state the same time that the switches are remotely operated

6.1 Modified Switch Controller

Opto-isoloated Remote Switch Position Indicator
Opto-isolated switch position indicator

Schematic and Drawings for Opto-Isolated Remote Switch Position Indicator

6.2 Atlas Snap Switch based switch Direction Detection

Atlas Snap Switch Remote Switch Position Indicator
Atlas Snap Switch switch position indicator

Drawing of Atlas Snap Switch position indicator

6.3 Modifed Switch

The following shows what I'm currently using, which are modified switches. In my first version, I used a magnetic reed switch and a strong rare-earth magnet. I used hot-melt glue to glue the magnet to the shutter carriage and the reed switch to the casing. One mistake I made was to put the connector on the inside of the switch. This connector is an obstruction for long passenger cars on the curved section of track.

Rev A modified switch with Switch Position Indicator
Rev A modified switch with magnetic reed switch position sensor

Internals of Rev A modified switch with Switch Position Indicator
Internals of Rev A modified switch with magnetic reed switch position sensor

In my second version, I used a hall-effect sensor (Cherry Corporation MP101301, Jameco 513244), and used a DIN connector. Like before used a strong rare-earth magnet (From Radio Shack) hot-melt glued tothe shutter carriage and the sensor hot-melt glued to the case.

Rev B modified switch with Switch Position Indicator
Rev B modified switch with a hall-effect sensor to sense direction

Internals of Rev B modified switch with Switch Position Indicator
Internals of Rev B modified switch showing hall effect sensor and magnet

Both versions of the modified switches work well from a sensor perspective. If a connector is used, it should not be installed on the track side of the control box because of potential interference with train cars. The pigtail (with appropriate strain relief) used with Rev B seems to work well.
Directly sensing of the switch position within the switch itself improves system reliability by preventing problems when someone manually changes the direction of the switch.

7. Block Controller

7.1 Single Block Controller

Block Controller
Block Controllers

The Block Controller enables control logic to switch the source of power (or turn power on or off) for a block of track. It also can emulate the American Flyer Lockout Elminator which stops a train without causing the reversing unit to activate and start the engine in reverse after power is re-applied to the block.
Block Controller Circuit

7.2 Dual Block Controller

Here's a modified block controller used as a dual block inhibit for the two entry blocks

Dual Block Inhibit Controller
Dual Block Inhibit Controllers - December 2007

Dual Block Inhibit Controller Circuit

7.3 Shared Block Controller

Here's a shared block controller to control which transformer will control the shared block

Shared Block Controller
Shared Block Controller - December 2007

Shared Block Controller Circuit

8. Master Controller

8.1 Relay Controller

Master Controller - Dec 2003
Master controller in December 2003

The Master Controller determines which train should have control of the shared block, and generates the proper signals for the Block Controllers, the Remote Switch Controller, and the Block Signal. The circuit is a combination of Relay Logic and signal conditioning. In 2007 I replaced this control box with a microprocessor based (Commodore 64) controller.
Master Controller Circuit

8.2 Commodore 64 Based Controller

The Serial Port Break-out box enables a computer (such as a Commodore 64) to send 8 bits of output control signals and receive 8 bits of control signal inputs. The code was written in assembly language, assembled using my own CA cross-assembler (Dowload CA cross-assembler here) and burned into an EPROM. Bought several Game Cartridge boards with sockets off of EBay to hold the EPROMs.

Commodore 64 Train Control Assembly Language Code and Binary

Commodore 64 Screen Shot
Commodore 64 Train Control Screen Shot (on Monochrome Monitor)

Commodore 64
Commodore 64 with RS-232 interface and Game Cartridge Board with EPROM

Serial Port Break-out box
Serial Port Break-out Box - Dec 2007

Serial Port Break-Out Box Circuit

8.3 PC Based Controller

In December 2010 I rewrote the train control software in C for running on a laptop using LINUX as the operating system. I used a USB to Serial Port converter to interface with the Serial Port Break-out box.

PC Train Control Software Code

PC Control System
PC Control System (running on LINUX)


8.3 Arduino Based Controller

In 2015 I developed an Arduino based controller for the shared block control for my permnanent layout. The Arduino has a major advantage over a PC in that it boots up in seconds. The Human Machine Interface (HMI) is pretty simple. A three way toggle switch can lock operation for either train, or run in auto. In Auto mode, the first train to reach its control block has access to the shared block while the other train is blocked from entering the shared block. While in automatic mode, a Reset button can force the logic to reset and wait for the next train to enter its control block. The Caboose Block Control Reset will be implemented in the future to block trains should one or more cars inadvertantly decouple -- this hasn't been implemented yet. A two line serial display presents the status of all the inputs and outputs as well as the logic state

Arduino Control System HMI
Interface for Arduino Control System for Shared Block Control

Arduino Control System Board
Circuit board for Arduino Control System for Shared Block Control

Arduino Control System Box
Controller Box for Arduino Control System for Shared Block Control

Circuit and layout for Arduino Based Controller
Software for Arduino Based Controller

9. Emergency Stop

Emergency Stop
Emergency Stop

This circuit implements an emergency stop for 3 transformers
Emergency Stop Circuit

10. Block Signal

Block Signal Front
Block Signal

The Master Controller generates signals for a block signal for the entrance of the shared block. Here is a diagram of a block signal I made. The hoods for the lights were made from straws. I hid the resistors for the LEDs in the base block.
Block Signal

11. Railroasd Crossing Control

Railroad Crossing Flashing Controller
I wanted my crossing signals to flash like the real ones, so I built this circuit. It also allows you to alternately flash two 12V lights for even more realism.
Rail Crossing Flashing Control Circuit

Another Railroad Crossing Flashing Controller
This circuit alternately flashes both lights on an American Flyer 760 Highway Flasher without having to modify the 760 unit. It does replace the lightbulbs with Light Emitting Diodes.
AF 760 Rail Crossing Alternate Flashing Control Circuit

Yet Another 760 Rail Crossing Flashing Control AF 760 converted to LED
Yet another AF 760 Rail Crossing Alternate Flashing Control Circuit
AF 760 Rail Crossing Alternate Flashing Control Circuit (a bit newer)

12. Handcar Auto-reversing Control

Handcar Auto-Reversing
Handcar Auto-Reversing Control Box
Handcar Auto-Reversing Movie
Movie of Auto-Reversing -- Christmas 2006 (Click Picture to View)

This circuit automatically reverses the direction of a handcar that has been converted to DC. It uses two track trips to sense when the handcar should reverse direction and changes the polarity of the power applied to the track.
Hand Car Controller Circuit

13. Remote 120V control

Remote 120V Control
Remote 120V Control

This circuit allows me turn on remote transformers for my accessories when control power is provided by the train control transformers.

Remote 120V Control Circuit Diagram

14. Transformer Considerations

12B and 22030 transformers
12B (250 Watt) and 22030 (100 Watt) transformers for engine control

4B transformer
4B (100 Watt) transformer for remote switches

22004 transformer
22004(40 Watt) transformer for accessories

GFCI Outlet
GFCI Outlet for safety

The American Flyer transformers are very robust and work well over 50 years since they were manufactured. That said, one has to be careful when using these old electrical devices. I personally plug the transformers into a GFCI (Ground Fault Current Interrupter) protected outlet. I also inspect the power cords every year and replace any that are cracked. Consider using a 3 prong grounded cord as a replacement cord. Connect the green wire to the metal case or base of the transformer. This will cause your home circuit breaker to trip in the event of an internal short of the hot conductor to the case of the transformer.

I dedicate a number 4 transformer to the remote switches. Operating a remote switch causes a noticable voltage sag, so I prefer to isolate the impact of this on the rest of the system.

I use a 12B, 22030 or a 4B transformer for operating the trains. The 100 - 125 watts per train is sufficient to run the engines, especially if the transformers aren't used for accessories.

For the rest of the accessories, I use a 40 or 50 watt transformer (such as a 22004). The lower wattage is adequate, and in the case of a short circuit results in a lower short circuit current (and hopefully less damage).
So in a typical layout, I have a total of 4 transformers: 2 for engine control, 1 for switch control, 1 for accessories.

Note that this does not count the 12VDC transformer for the IO Box/Master Controller or the power supply for the Computer.

15. Accessory Control Buttons

Accessory Control Button
Accessory Control Button

Since my layouts are tempory, but still soemwhat complex, I've made some effort to improve reliability of the wiring. One thing that really helps is to use terminal strips and wiring with spade terminals. For the accessory buttons, I mounted them onto a piece of wood and wired them to a terminal strip. I've found that a 7 connector terminal strip works great:

2 terminals for power in (Black and Yellow)
2 terminals for daisy-chaining to the next accessory control button (Black and Yellow)
2 terminals for power to the accessory (Black and Yellow)
1 terminal connected to the push button switch. (Green)

NOTE: Black is for the base terminal on the transformer, Yellow for the Accessory Terminal

For some of the control buttons, I included a slide switch to determine whether the Green terminal connects to the Yellow or the Black terminal through the push button switch. Most accessories need the pushbutton to connect to the Yellow terminal, so I've hard wired a number of accessory buttons in this way.

16. Reverse Loops


Reverse Loop

A reverse loop exists anytime a train can traverse the same stretch of track in opposite directions while travelling forward. As shown in the following figure, reverse loops can cause electrical short circuits if not properly addressed.


The Electrical Problem due to Reverse Loops

The following block diagram shows the elements of operating with a reverse loop. For AC systems, the normal solution to prevent a short circuit is to use isolation (fiber) pins to isolate a section of track (or at least the outside rails). Either a switch or a relay is used to control the "polarity" of this isolated section of track based on the whether the switch is in the straight or curve position. For fully automatic operation, a switch controller will automatically throw the switch when the train is approaching the switch from within the reverse loop.


Reverse Loop Control Block Diagram

Gilbert made a "No. 695 Reverse Loop Relay" which detected the switch position by using a dual winding latching relay that sensed when the switch coils were energized. This relay also provided the proper "polarity" connection to the outside rails of the reverse loop. The inside rails are controlled by the "2 Train Operation" button on the remote switch. The following picture shows an emulation of this reverse loop relay. It differs from the 695 in that it does not use a latching relay (and therefore on power up may not reflect the proper setting of the switch). It also differs in that it provides the option to completely isolate the reverse loop track and power both rails through this reverse loop relay.


Emulator of No. 695 Reverse Loop Relay

No 695 Reverse Loop Relay Emulation Schematic

The previous controller only changed the polarity of a track section baseed on the last set of switch coils that were energized. The following controller relies on an external switch direction sensor, but in addition to changing polarity of a track section, also changes the position of the switch when the train is fully in the reverse loop.


Fully automatic reverse loop controller (click on picture for video)

Schematic for Fully Automatic Reverse Loop Controller


100. THINGS I TRIED THAT DIDN'T WORK

100.1 Reed Switch based Current Sensing Track Trip

This trip consists of a Reed Switch that has many turns of wire wrapped around it. You connect the windings in series with the track power of an isolated block. When the engine draws power from the track block, current in the windings generates a magnetic field that closes the contacts. The only problem with A.C. power is that the reed switch actually becomes a buzzer. My experience is that the rapid opening and closing of the reed switch with even a small sensing current will quickly cause the reed switch to over heat and the reeds will fuze together.

100.2 Microswitch with roller track trip

Tried to automate the changing of direction of a handcar (converted to DC) by having the handcar brush up alongside a roller microswitch. Unfortunately, it still had enough friction so that the handcar often stuck when it was trying to start in the reverse direction.


Return to Norbert's American Flyer Trains
Return to Norbert's Home Page